'Review will eradicate obvious errors' – Richardson

Richardson: ‘Should we have a system where the umpire is given an opportunity to review his own decision and make a final decision himself? That would be preferable.’ © AFP
 

Terming the new umpire referral system a ‘review process’ as opposed to a challenge process, Dave Richardson, the ICC’s general manager, was confident it would work well on a long-term basis with plenty of room for improvement. He said most umpires were in favour of this system and the real purpose is to eradicate obvious mistakes.”Our policy in the decision-making process has always been to keep an open mind,” he said. “You will recall in Sri Lanka in the 2002 Champions Trophy when we first started experimenting with technology and it continued until the Super Series in 2005, during which we allowed umpires to initiate a consultation on decisions. That didn’t work because the umpires didn’t refer decisions they should have. And then when they discovered that they could have made mistakes they became over cautious.”It was actually just wasting time. They were double-checking themselves and this lead to a loss of confidence of the players in the umpires. We realised it doesn’t work.”A lot of people will say reviews are contradictory to the spirit of the game and that players are challenging the umpires, but the way we look at it is – what is better or worse for the game? Umpires make mistakes and are accused of cheating, Steve Bucknor’s effigies are being burnt, teams threaten to fly home from a country, boards criticise umpires. Should we have a system where the umpire is given an opportunity to review his own decision and make a final decision himself? That would be preferable.”Richardson, who was present in the South African Test side when the first third-umpire referral was made in 1992-93, was firm that the ICC was not paying the television channels for the use of this technology, but rather saw it as a piggyback process. “The very first step in this process was to approach Ten Sports (the main broadcasters) and ask if they were willing to help us. They were keen to do so and we are very grateful to them. The broadcasters, like it or not, have been guilty in the past of showing up the umpires. All we ask them to do is continue to do so, but help us instead of being negative.”The ICC normally appoints three neutral Elite Panel umpires for a series. For this contest, instead of one umpire rotating and taking a break, he will act as the official third umpire. This, according to Richardson, was the way it would be going forward and there may even be the case of recalling some more experienced umpires to be specialist television umpires. But that, he affirmed, would be based on how the players felt about the situation.

Richardson on Steve Bucknor’s removal from the Perth Test in January

  • “There were calls for Steve to be fired permanently and we have resisted that. He’s a good umpire and he’s had a long career. The reason for taking him out was because of the hype which made it impossible for him to stand in that Test. He was on a hiding to nothing. The slightest error would have been blown out of proportion. To make it easier on him and his colleagues in that Test, we decided to rest him and so diffuse the situation.”

Over the last few days the ICC has worked with the company that provides the ball-tracking device. Cameras have been placed in correct positions around the SSC and both parties have confirmed the accuracy of the results. Camera use will differ from series to series but there are minimum specifications, clarified Richardson.The company being used to provide the ball tracking is not Hawk-Eye, as generally employed, but one called Virtual Eye. They are similar to Hawk-Eye, said Richardson, but the ICC would only use the actual path of the ball until it hits the batsman. “It will then stop, and we won’t use the predictive element because the suppliers of that technology will say that it’s a bit of a computer guess.”The trickiest part is going to be for the batsman,” said Richardson. “As far as caught-behinds and bat-pads are concerned I have no doubt that every batsman, if he is honest with himself, will know he’s got the finest edge. But I can understand as a batsman that you are uncertain as to whether the ball pitched on leg stump or slightly outside. It might be tricky and we may find a circumstance that you get back into the dressing room and your coach has spoken to you for not challenging the decision or asking for it to be reviewed. We must not forget what the real object of this system is – to eradicate obvious mistakes.”

Pakistan set for victory in Harare Test

Pakistan, barring an unexpected intervention from the weather, are practicallycertain to win the first Test match against Zimbabwe at the Harare Sports Club,thanks to contrasting centuries by Inzamam-ul-Haq and Taufeeq Umer againstinept Zimbabwean bowling. Zimbabwe, needing 420 to win, finished with 19for one.Zimbabwe began the day with hopes that history might repeat itself and asimilar victory from behind as that at Peshawar in 1998/99 might bepossible. Henry Olonga, a hero on that occasion, soon bowled a lifting ballthat struck Younis Khan (8) painfully on the fingers and flew to AlistairCampbell in the slips, reducing Pakistan to 25 for two. Then Inzamam gotoff the mark with a snick that flew just over the head of Andy Flower atfirst slip and went to the boundary. Had it been just a little lower, thestory of the day’s play might have been very different.But that was Zimbabwe’s last sniff, and they had only themselves to blame asthey surrendered the match in the pre-lunch session. Olonga never put ittogether consistently, and at one stage bounced a ball so high over the headsof batsman Inzamam and wicket-keeper Tatenda Taibu that it went for a totalof five wides. His partners at the other end were no more efficient, andshort medium-fast deliveries outside off stump are meat and drink toInzamam. He enjoyed a feast of boundaries and his fifty came up off 53balls, containing no fewer than 12 fours. When he reached 32 he became onlythe second Pakistani, after the legendary Javed Miandad, to reach 6,000 runsin Test cricket. The television suggested, though, that he was perhapslucky to survive an lbw appeal when on 40 to Raymond Price as soon as hecame on to bowl, umpire Dave Orchard disagreeing.Zimbabwe’s economic disasters have not destroyed the generous nature of herpeople, and Pakistan were so grateful for the vast number of four-balls onoffer that the hundred came up in the 19th over. Zimbabwe’s fielding becamerather ragged, and in the last over before lunch Inzamam joined the selectband who have scored a century before lunch in a Test match, although it wasan extended session due to time lost on the second day. It took him 102balls and 138 minutes. All credit to Pakistan; they were given theirchances and took them superbly.After lunch the contest briefly became keen again. Inzamam hammered Olongafor two more fours and then smashed a ball straight to Grant Flower atbackward point. He departed reluctantly, perhaps sensing anothertriple-century wasted. Yousuf Youhana uncharacteristically hung his bat outto be caught at the wicket off Andy Blignaut without scoring, and suddenly,briefly, Zimbabwe threatened again. Taufeeq became becalmed, while HasanRaza took a long time to get going. But slowly they put Pakistan back ontop, and after Raza departed to a catch at mid-off the debutant KamranAkmal, after a slow start, hit some impressive blows.Taufeeq crawled towards his century, moving from 70 at lunch to 97 at tea,27 off 83 balls. A misfield by Price allowed him to reach three figures off197 deliveries, in five hours. He finally fell for 115, caught down the legside off Blignaut and walking without waiting for the apparently indecisiveumpire Orchard. Kamran had already been bowled by Price and now Blignautbowled Waqar Younis.Pakistan were 318 for eight, to add to their lead of 60 on first innings.Then came a period of village green cricket, as tail-enders Saqlain Mushtaqand Shoaib Akhtar tried to indulge in some spectacular baseball oragricultural strokes against the second new ball, taken by Blignaut andOlonga, neither of whom seemed able to put the ball on the wicket or producethe leg-stump yorker that would almost certainly have ended the slog.Zimbabwe seemed to have lost all purpose, and the last two wickets wereallowed to add 51. Olonga finished with five wickets, but one cannot say hewas impressive.Zimbabwe, batting just before the close until bad light again curtailedplay, soon lost Hamilton Masakadza (0), superbly caught by short leg SaleemElahi off Shoaib Akhtar. Dion Ebrahim and Alistair Campbell at leastsurvived with sensible positive play until the close.

Dolphins awarded match after thrilling tie

Baqai Dolphins entered into the semifinals of the 17th Karachi Gymkhana Callmate Festival after having tied their match against Sindh Police Friday.Having first use of the wicket after winning the toss, Baqai Dolphins had a sound start of 102 by Maisam Husnain (55) and Man of the Match Atiq-ur-Zaman (50) but collapsed to be bowled out for 175 in 19.4 overs in a match restricted to 20 overs.Sindh Police got oof to a splendid start when Kamran Hussain (56) and Akif Alvi (27) put on 85 for the first wicket. Kamran slashed eight fours and three sixes in his 27-ball knock and Akif clobbered four boundaries and a six off 15 deliveries.With three overs remaining Sindh Police needed 21 runs for victory with three wickets in hand. But two run outs left the Police trailing by 15 runs with the last man in and only an over left.Taking two runs off the first ball and heaving the next for a six and a single off the third, Iftikhar Ali brought his team closer to victory now needing six runs to win with three deliveries to spare. Off the last ball two runs were needed to win and as the two batsmen scampered home for the winning run, Ahmed Iqbal was run out and the match was tied with both teams dismissed for 175 runs.Baqai Dolphins were awarded the match on a faster run rate.Saturday’s fixture: (Quarterfinals) Dewan Mushtaq Sugar Mills v KESC at 1-30 p.m.KESC in semis Karachi Electric Supply Corporation (KESC), cruised into the semifinal of the Eighth Tapal Trophy Ramazan Festival tournament beating Defence Housing Authority (DHA) CC by seven wickets Friday.Winning the toss and batting first, DHA were bundled out for 89 in 20 overs with Moin Khan contributing 28 to his team’s score. Spinners Irfanuddin three for 11 and Asif Ghouri three for 17 did the damage.KESC lost both openers with 22 on the board. But Man of the Match Arif Mehmood 43 not out and Imran Javed (26), steered their team to a comfortable victory as KESC scored 95 for three in 18 overs.Aleem’s hostile spell A hostile spell of pace bowling by the Man of the Match Aleem Khan Moosa enabled Mohammad Hussain CC enter the final of the Seventh Danish Trophy Ramazan Tournament, after knocking out last year’s champions Rangers Gymkhana by 26 runs Friday.In a match restricted to 18 overs Mohammad Hussain CC winning the toss and batting first reached 123 for eight wickets, with Nisar Abbas (31) and Arslan Jawed (30) scoring the bulk of runs.Rangers Gymkhana were ahead on the run rate until Aleem Khan Moosa’s hostile spell in which he captured three wickets for 26 runs turned the tide.Saeed Tamoir top scored for the losing side with 29 runs and Saeed Ahmed chipped in with 20.Saturday’s fixture: KGA Gymkhana v Wakenhut CC 1-30 p.m.Eaglets in final Karachi Eaglets moved into the final of the Kareemuddin Colour Kit Ramazan Festival tournament getting the better of Rafiq Sherazi CC by 80 runs.Batting first, Karachi Eaglets raced to 215 for the loss of four wickets in the 20 overs through Mohammad Waheed (55), Khurram Abbas (47), Kashif Hanif (37 n.o.) and Asim Cheema (26).Sheerazi CC were dismissed for 135 in 15.1 overs. Shahid Dawood top scored with 41 and Asif Ghori made 26. Khurram Abbas later named the Man of the Match bagged three for 16.

Youhana incident: A lesson to be learnt by all

LAHORE-The Pakistan cricket team has an uncanny knack of inviting unnecessary trouble and controversy. The latest one hitting the headlines involving Yousuf Youhana falls in the same category.It is really good that Youhana, after revealing his account of the whole episode, has got some measure of reprieve straightaway from the PCB Chairman.The most unassuming of the whole lot, to the point of being docile, Youhana was sent back from Kenya on charges of insubordination. He was accused of not following skipper Waqar Younis? instructions to appear at the nets. And cut to the quick, Younis saw to it that Youhana – the most consistent and the highest run-getter under Waqar – was sent back in disgrace.It is entirely another thing that Youhana was the wronged party, and twice so if his version is to be believed. And we have no reason not to give credence to it, because the PCB apparently accepts his version of events, which is quite apparent from the press release issued after he met Lt. Gen Tauqir Zia, the PCB Chairman.According to the press release, Youhana informed the Chairman that he “had been carrying a shoulder injury from Tangiers, which was not given due attention by the team doctor at an early stage.” An MRI scan, much later in Nairobi, confirmed that he did have a shoulder problem.”I was doing individual training on the ground, but did not go for the nets because my shoulder was under treatment then”, says the PCB press release quoting Youhana.”Youhana for his part assured the Chairman that his not going for the nets, as skipper Younis demanded, was neither deliberate nor an intention to shirk usual training”, said the press release.Again quoting Youhana, the press release says: “Let me state that I want to perform for my country to the best of my ability. And I have utmost respect and regard not just for the Pakistan captain but all seniors as well. I regret any unintentional offense that I may have caused”.The Chairman’s verdict, after he spoke to Younis and team management on the phone [read confirming Youhana’s version]: “The tour disciplinary committee was fully authorised to take the action that they have and indiscipline should neither be tolerated nor condoned. Still in my considered opinion, the whole incident was a bit overblown.”So, while the PCB would be making every effort that there is no compromise on discipline, at the same time every endeavour would also be made that team spirit and camaraderie was not sacrificed by magnifying events and incidents that were otherwise not grave in nature”.Both Yousuf Youhana and captain Waqar Younis, says the press release, wholeheartedly agree to this assessment of the situation. And in what is indeed an honourable acquittal for Youhana, “The PCB was likely to take a sympathetic view in case of Youhana because of his unblemished disciplinary record. He has immediately been handed in to the care of Dr Tauseef Razzaq to attend to his shoulder injury so that he regains full fitness as soon as possible”.One doesn’t have to read between the lines to deduce from the press release that, though he has chosen to back the tour management to the extent of not overturning its verdict, Lt Gen Tauqir Zia is totally unconvinced about the rationale of such an extreme measure. And rightly so. Whether the captain and the tour management are wise enough to take their cue from this is a moot point.It is a shame anyway that such an incident happened. And to avoid a repeat, Waqar Younis would be well-advised to remember that a skipper has to be above getting perked up at imaginary slights, settling of scores and browbeating his charges. That is if he wants to command respect, and lead the outfit to victories.

England fly to Brisbane with renewed confidence

PERTH, Oct 31 AAP – The England cricket team will fly to Brisbane today with renewed belief for the upcoming Ashes series after a much improved showing in a three-day tour match against Western Australia.The tourists ran out of time to win the tour match falling just five runs short in a thrilling final session, being stranded at 5-130, after chasing 135 to win from 20 overs.Quick Simon Jones’ five-wicket haul and the early form of opener Robert Key, a late replacement for Graham Thorpe (missed tour for personal reasons), should be encouraging for England.Jones persisted on a flat WACA track and ended up taking 5-78 while Key’s unbeaten 59 was nearly enough for the tourists to snatch an unlikely win.The 23-year-old Key scored 33 in the opening innings and 68 in the opening tour match against an ACB Chairman’s XI and looks a fine strokeplayer.England has a three-day tour match against Queensland starting Saturday in Brisbane before the opening Ashes Test.Much interest will centre around whether allrounder Andy Flintoff and opener Michael Vaughan will be fit to play with a hit-out before the opening Test on Thursday almost considered mandatory.Flintoff is recovering from a hernia operation while Vaughan also has been unable to play since a minor knee operation last month.Spearhead Darren Gough, who has not played a Test match for more than 12 months, is considered highly unlikely to be fit for the Gabba Test.But Welshman Jones said the team had taken confidence out of the three-day match against the Warriors after a sub-par opening week.”I think we done very well to get within five runs,” Jones said.”Robert Key played outstandingly well I thought, he’s been in great nick for most of the tour.”Jones said despite being unable to register its first win of the tour, the England touring party was upbeat after the match.”There’s a great feeling in the camp, definitely,” he said.

Sri Lankan manager's contract not to be renewed

Sri Lanka’s manager Chandra Shaffter has been told by the Board of Controlfor Cricket in Sri Lanka (BCCSL) that his contract will not be renewed afterthe current tour of England.Anura Tennekoon, the BCCSL’s chief executive, broke the news to Shaffterduring a telephone conversation before the start of the third days play atOld Trafford.PA News Agency claimed that the decision to end his contract followed acomplaint from the new chairman of selectors, Guy de Alwis, to the BCCSLthat he had been denied entry to the dressing room during the Second npowerTest at Birmingham.It’s an allegation that’s flatly denied by Shaffter: "Guy de Alwis neverrequested access to the dressing room, so how could I possibly deny it?"Shaffter, 72, was controversially appointed days before the Asian TestChampionship final in March, replacing Air Commodore Ajit Jayasekera, who isnow a member of the interim committee that runs the BCCSL.He was given a short-term contract that included a Sharjah triangular seriesin April and Sri Lanka’s tour of England.Jayasekera is considered the favourite candidate to replace Shaffter.

Ranatunga: ICC Champions Trophy is stepping-stone for 2011 World Cup

Arjuna Ranatunga has congratulated the International Cricket Council for theirdecision to host the ICC Champions Trophy in Sri Lanka, hoping that it willprovide a stepping-stone to the eventual hosting of a World Cup.But Ranatunga, who has already announced his ambitions to be president ofthe Board of Control for Cricket in Sri Lanka (BCCSL), also warned that thetournament’s successful management will depend on the quality of theadministration running the cricket board.”All lovers of cricket in Sri Lanka will be elated by the decision of theICC.which should be view as recognition of the standards set by ourcricketers who have contributed to placing Sri Lanka on the world cricketmap.”He hopes that the event will “inspire future generations of cricketers tomaintain and surpass these high standards” as well as paving the way for thefuture hosting of the World Cup, possibly in 2011.”By successfully carrying out this competition, Sri Lanka can show thecricketing world that it can conduct the World Cup at not so distant a datein the future, probably in 2011,” he said.But he has concerns: “It’s necessary that people of dedication andcommitment should be at the helm of affairs of Sri Lankan cricket if thiscompetition is to be held successfully, and not by adventurers oropportunists, whose only concern is their own benefit.”

New Zealand Under-19s romp to innings win in three days

New Zealand made an emphatic start to the Youth Test series with South Africa today when wrapping up the First Test by an innings and 67 runs in Alexandra.South Africa was all out for 183 after Wellington left-arm spinner Luke Woodcock took 3/29 from his 25 overs while medium-pacer Andrew Ellis bowled 11 overs into the wind to take 2/6 as the South African resistance was broken.When play started 45 minutes late at Alexandra there seemed a good chance that this contest would go into the fourth and final day.But although there were at least two light showers, the weather didn’t halt New Zealand’s progress.South Africa started the day at 72/2 and desperately needed two of theirbatsmen to score big but it was not to be as a steady procession of themmade their way pavilionward, most playing shots far too early in theirinnings.Only Hashim Amla 69 and Warren Hauptfleish 37 showed much in the way of resilience.The pitch was very good for batting as the New Zealanders had proven with their 400.Brendon McCullum’s 123 was instrumental in getting New Zealand to their match winning total of 400; he also kept wickets well and captained his side withcompetence. New Zealand fielded better than South Africa and this also was a telling factor.But perhaps foreign conditions, as well as steady New Zealand bowling, proved the downfall of the visitors.New Zealand manager Dayle Hadlee said he was surprised New Zealand were able to win som emphatically in the first match of the series.”We expected more of a feeling out Test where both teams would be gauging the strengths and weaknesses of each other.”I think South Africa under-achieved a little. Steven Cook, the son of former international Jimmy Cook, looked a very promising player. In fact, their top four batsmen look as though they can play pretty well.”They missed their two best bowlers who are out with injury. Johan Botha broke a bone in his foot playing Otago and he will be out for all the games,” he said.Hadlee said New Zealand’s batting was helped by Brendon McCullum’s brisk scoring rate while the running between the wickets was very good..”It was a good toss to lose. We were erring towards bowling first but when South Africa won the toss we were quite happy they chose to bat first.”He said the pace bowlers Taraia Robin and Ian Butler bowled well in the first innings while in the second Luke Woodcock and the unsung hero of the day Andrew Ellis did the damage.”Andrew kept it very tight for us and bowled well into the wind,” he said.South Africa could well be a force in the one-day series to come but with New Zealand one up in the three match Test series they will have to battle very hard to achieve success in the remaining two ‘tests’.The South African team have proved very good ambassadors for their country in Otago and cricket people who have met them are sorry to see them go – it is certain that some of them will be South African representatives of the future as indeed will be some of the New Zealanders.

Pakistan in England: Review of previous tours

England and Pakistan cricketing relations are fifty years old. These ties commenced when Nigel Howards’ MCC team broke-off their Indian leg of the tour in 1951-52 and played two unofficial Test Matches in Pakistan. After the drawn first test at Lahore they lost at Karachi by 4 wickets. Three years later Pakistan achieved the unprecedented feat, on their first tour of England in 1954, by winning one test and thus drawing the series. No other team later or before have managed to win a test on their first visit. Since that historic tour, out of 57 Test Matches played between the two countries England have won 15 against 9 by Pakistan. Shortly, the Pakistan team is scheduled to tour England to play two Test Matches and later to participate in a triangular one-day tournament involving Australia as the third team.Summary of previous results
In terms of results of previous tours, Pakistan’s record against England is dismal – only seven Test and five One-Day victories have been recorded. On the other hand, England enjoys distinct supremacy by virtue of their 12 victories in Test Matches and 15 One-Day wins. In spite of this numerical difference on overall results, Pakistan has been dominating since 1987. They have won all the last three Test series played in England.Looking at all the One-Day Internationals played between England and Pakistan, again the record is not all that healthy. Out of 46 ODI’s played between the two teams, England won 28 and Pakistan won only 17. The one match between the two that ended in no-result, more fortunately in Pakistan’s favour, was washed out at the Adelaide Oval during World Cup 1992.The forthcoming tour will be Pakistan’s eleventh trip to England.Brief highlights of Pakistan’s previous tours of England:
1954 – Series was drawn 1-1. Fazal Mahmood was the architect of the famous “Oval Victory”.
1962 – Worst era for Pakistan Cricket began with this Series lost 0-4. England amassed huge scores and truly cut Pakistan down to size. Mercifully, rain saved Pakistan in the Fourth Test at Nottingham from a 0-5 drubbing.
1967 – Series lost 0-2. Hanif Mohammad’s 187 not out saved Pakistan at Lords and a 190 run record 9th wicket partnership between Asif Iqbal and Intikhab Alam salvaged their honour at the Oval.
1971 – Series lost 0-1. This Series somewhat unjustly eluded Pakistan. Zaheer Abbas scored 274 and England had followed-on but rain cost Pakistan victory at Edgbaston. At Headingley, in the third test except for the last day, they had held the upper hand.
1974 – Series was drawn 0-0. After Sir Donald Bradman’s 1948 team, Pakistan were the only other touring team to remain unbeaten on an England tour. Zaheer Abbas scored 240 at the Oval.
1978 – Series was lost 0-2. Pakistan team was not at full strength and Botham was their chief tormentor with both bat and ball.
1982 – Series was lost 1-2. Honours remained pretty even throughout and the series was closely fought. Imran Khan was the man of the series. Mohsin Khan scored a superb 200 at Lords.
1987 – Series was won 1-0. Imran Khan claimed his 300th wicket and led Pakistan to victory at Headingley. Javed Miandad scored 260 and Pakistan recorded their highest innings total, 708 at the Oval where England were forced to follow-on but escaped defeat.
1992 – Series was won 2-1. England had no answer to the reverse swing of Wasim Akram and Waqar Younis. Aamer Sohail made 205 at Old Trafford. England won at Headingley and Pakistan won at Lords and the Oval.
1996 – Series was won 2-0. Saeed Anwar, Inzamam-ul-Haq and Ijaz Ahmed gave outstanding batting performances. Waqar Younis was again the successful bowler.2001 – A tough contest expected in the forthcoming series:
Ironically, Pakistan has not lived up to the great reputation, they generally enjoy, in the last few test series. Still, the team is ranked amongst the best along with Australia and South Africa for their overall ability and the tremendous potential they possess. On the other hand England, has shown remarkable consistency by winning four successive Test series against Zimbabwe, West Indies, Pakistan and Sri Lanka. They have applied themselves with sound professional technique and have played methodical cricket. Followers of the game are expecting a tough and competitive test series between the two teams followed by the Triangular One-Day tournament.

ZCO editorial, volume 3 issue 30

The final round of the Logan Cup competition is to be played this coming weekend, with Mashonaland, who play the CFX Academy, virtually assured of the championship, quite possibly by winning all five of their matches as they did last season. Unfortunately we have not yet received an updated table from ZCU. There was to have been a great finish to the season with an Australian tour, just the boost Zimbabwean cricket-lovers would have longed for to take their minds off these difficult times, but the Australians considered politics (however futile their aim) to be of greater importance, and the ICC compiled.With no action in Harare and the main performers of the drawn match last weekend between Manicaland and Matabeleland unavailable for interview in Harare, this is a brief issue. We plan two more issues this season, as we should be able to interview a number of players at the Mashonaland-Academy match this weekend. In this issue we have updated the biography of Matabeleland’s Wisdom Siziba. Larry Moyo reports on the close of the club cricket season, and we have been given approval to include the official reports of the recent Under-16 tournament by the organizer and Matabeleland team manager Richard Harrison.

Game
Register
Service
Bonus